Thursday, June 18, 2009

Honesty is the Best Policy


by Steve Fodor

I was in a meeting with a new client yesterday and I had what I would call a very refreshing experience.

You never know how things are going to go with a new client. It’s sort of like being on a first date and you don’t really know the other person yet. You think to yourself, “If I say this, will I offend them? Or will they think I’m too forward?”

Well, this particular client asked me what I thought about some of their current marketing materials (Yikes…now I was on the spot. And my boss was with me, too.) Well, I gave them a very honest, respectful and professional opinion. Their materials were written in a very literal, “one-dimensional” way. They did a good job of explaining the “what,” but did not translate information into a customer benefit. They used a lot of common, over-used terms like “value” and “quality.” In other words, there was room for improvement to give this brand some personality and make it connect with customers in more meaningful ways.

I spoke my mind. I was respectful, yet honest. And I qualified everything I said with past experience and examples.

After my pontification, our new client said, with a smile on his face, “Thank you for being honest. We need someone to keep us in check.”

New clients are hard to come by, especially in today’s economy. And if you’re in the agency business, the last thing you want to do is say or do something that will sour a relationship. But honesty, respect and trust are the foundation of any good business relationship. Clients will respect you a whole lot more when you lead by example and share your knowledge in a way that is not condescending. And the more I think about it, that’s true for just about anything in life.


Thursday, June 11, 2009

'Holy Schnike' -- It's Brand Equity

by Steve Fodor

It’s a long story, but I have the movie “Tommy Boy” running through my mind. Especially the line from the movie when Tommy (Chris Farley) says to a customer, “You can get a good look at a T-bone steak by sticking your head up a bull’s (rear end), but wouldn’t you rather take a butcher’s word for it?”

I’m thinking about this line from “Tommy Boy” because I’ve had yet another person comment that they can develop marketing communications as well as a proven and recognized agency (“proven” and “recognized” are the key words there). And you know what, in some cases that may be true.

I once heard that “brand equity is no different than home equity.” Brand image is the most valuable asset a company has. And, just like a home – many people’s most valuable asset – you can only go so far with “Do-It-Yourself” know-how. Sometimes you need to hire an expert. Someone with a proven track record. Someone who knows how to get it right the first time. Someone you can trust because they’ve done many other successful home improvement jobs. Because it’s more expensive to redo a job done wrong.

I see both good and bad marketing communications done in-house by companies. And I also see both good and bad creative work from a lot of agencies, too. The point is, your brand needs to be updated, maintained and presented in its most positive light. And, from my point of view, real creativity means knowing how to develop a strong message – on a budget.

You only have one chance to make a first impression. Making a good first impression and “saving a few pennies.” That reminds me of another great scene from “Tommy Boy.” Enjoy the video clip!


Tommy Boy sales training

Video Credit: video.google.com

Tuesday, June 9, 2009

Live For Today?


by Steve Fodor

I heard an interview on National Public Radio recently (yes, I’m a late night, talk radio junkie). Philip Delves-Broughton, an English journalist who attended Harvard Business School, was interviewed about his recent book, “What They Teach You at Harvard Business School.”

There were many interesting points discussed during the 20-minute interview. However, the most interesting point I took away was how the curriculum at Harvard, from the author’s point of view, focuses on business strategies for achieving short-term, immediate gains versus long-term, sustained performance.

Interesting, in light of where the economy is today, and why it’s that way.

It got me thinking about the value of a brand. A brand’s value is not just measured in short-term awareness and sales. It’s measured in real dollars over time. In sales that last decades, not months. In why people will pay more for your brand versus a seemingly similar product at a lower price.

I once heard a “brand” defined as, “the process of creating a constellation of values for forging a strong bond with customers to create loyalty.” Wow. To me, that sounds like investing time and energy to understand why people purchase something for reasons that go beyond price. It’s hard to resist the urge to “live for today” and focus on short-term sales and promotions. Especially in today’s economy. But, in the long run, successful brands always command higher margins. And, in return, strong brands are rewarded with greater customer loyalty, ultimately lowering the cost-per-sale and delivering a greater return on investment over time.

I wonder if they teach that at Harvard?

Monday, June 8, 2009

B2B versus B2C?


by Steve Fodor

Having worked in both worlds, I get asked this question a lot: What’s different about business-to-business marketing communications versus business-to-consumer?

Well, “nothing and everything” is usually my reply.

By “everything is different,” I mean that B2B usually means shaping your selling proposition into a business case. What kind of cost savings? What kind of productivity is achieved? B2B also requires a more in-depth understanding of selling scenarios. Selling through channel members or distributors and the need for push strategies, pull strategies…or usually a combination of both. And creating B2B marketing communications, I’ve found, requires a greater understanding of a product’s technical aspects.

Business-to-consumer marketing communications are generally more life-style appeal. Personal gratification is often at the root of a B2C selling proposition. How will this product make you feel? Will this make you the “hero” to your friends and family?

What’s the same about B2B and B2C marketing communications? To be effective and memorable, both recognize that you’re speaking first to people. Industrial buyers do not stop being people with emotions between the hours of 8:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. They still must be drawn in by an emotional appeal, and then presented a rational case for considering your product or service. The same is true when talking to private consumers.

Whether you’re marketing to housewives, product engineers, home improvement DIY folks, or chief financial officers, you need to understand how your product impacts their lives – be they private lives or professional lives. If you don’t understand how to connect with the emotional drivers, your brand will be “replaceable” when price is equal.

Flickr Photo Credit: http://www.flickr.com/photos/glasgows/

Friday, June 5, 2009

Seeking Perfection


by Steve Badertscher

I received an e-mail from my son’s teacher the other day informing me that one of his projects was late and still needed to be turned in before the end of the grading period or there would be grave consequences. (Not grave as in the cemetery variety, although judging by his mother’s reaction to this news that was a distinct possibility.)

When I inquired as to why the project in question had landed him in this predicament, he assured me that he had completed it…he just hadn’t turned it in yet.

At the risk of sounding somewhat dad-like, the next words out of my mouth were “And why not?”

Because, he explained, he just didn’t feel it was perfect yet.

On a dad-like roll, I pulled out the old “No one is perfect…that’s why pencils have erasers” quote. Unfortunately the old quote didn’t have quite the impact I had intended as he reminded me that we were discussing a multimedia project, which is created using a mouse and a keyboard, not a pencil. (Okay, that’s why laptops have a delete key, then!)

Nevertheless, I was able to get through to him that turning in an almost perfect project and receiving a B+ was a much better alternative to turning in nothing and being given a big, fat zero. He finally saw the wisdom in that and turned the project in the very next day (and I didn’t even have to mention the mom factor in the equation). I’m also happy to report he was rewarded with an A for his efforts.

Do you find yourself facing a similar situation where seeking perfection sometimes freezes you into doing nothing? I know I do.

But maybe we just need to remind ourselves every now and then that there are some jobs in life where perfection matters, like brain surgery, bomb detonating and parachute folding...

And there are other jobs where good enough is enough, like yard mowing, grocery bagging – and blog writing.

As an agency, we always like to strive for perfection, but what we do is part craft and part science, so mistakes are going to happen. Fortunately, when we do make a mistake in advertising, nobody dies in our arms.


Flickr Photo Credit: http://www.flickr.com/photos/tomsaint/

Thursday, June 4, 2009

The Value of Information


by Steve Fodor

My colleague, Brad Smith, recently posted some interesting information on banner ad click-thru rates we’ve tracked for a client. Two online versions of publications were used: one a traditional, editorially focused publication, the other a tabloid “shopper” publication with minimal editorial.

Interestingly, the editorially focused online publication outperformed the “shopper” publication by as much as 15 to one on banner ad click-thrus to the client’s Web site.

I’m not going to conclude that the “shopper” publication has no value. But, rather, the value of the editorial publication is the information it provides. Information is what engages people. How do I do my job better? How can I learn more? Don’t just tell me about product features. Tell me how it fits into my life or how to do my job better.

Information – or, I should say, valuable information – is becoming more of a commodity. I read recently that Facebook usage has increased from 1.7 billion minutes to 13 billion minutes over the last year. That’s a 665 percent increase. Twitter usage has increased 3,712 percent over the last year. Nielsen Online reports time spent on social networking and blogging sites has grown at three times the rate of overall Internet growth. And these aren’t all just kids with nothing better to do. The growth from the 35 to 64 age group is double that of under 18.

With so much information out there, so many distractions and so many new media usage trends, content truly is king in today’s information-intensive world. Think about what you’re saying to customers, be it in-person, on your Web site or in your advertising. Are you increasing your perceived brand value by providing information that’s of value…or are you just adding to the clutter?

Flickr Photo Credit: http://www.flickr.com/photos/wetwebwork/

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

What Kind of Trade Publication Works Best for Banner Ads?


by Brad Smith

We’ve been tracking the response rates for a client’s banner ads – electronic ads – placed on trade publication Web sites and e-newsletters. Simply put, we’re keeping track of the number of times readers “click-thru” to the client’s Web site directly from these ads.

Curiously, we have two publications in the same space that have delivered dramatically different results. One is what I call a “shopper” – a tabloid-size product-oriented magazine with minimal editorial – mostly ads and news releases. The other is the more traditional trade publication, with in-depth articles covering a broad variety of industry topics. Guess which pub has pulled the most click-thrus?

The traditional magazine’s Web site is outperforming the shopper 3:1. Their e-newsletter is out performing the shopper Web site 15:1.

Why? Good question. Both are viable, valuable assets to the media mix. However, I think the readers, who a good percentage of the time are the same people, approach these two types of trade publications with very different expectations.

The shopper is approached with an “I can find out about new products to make my job easier” mentality. That’s a quick read. Readers approach the more traditional publication with an “I can find out how to use new products and learn new ideas about my profession.” That’s a more in-depth read.

I conclude that the perceived image of the magazine is naturally extended to the electronic versions from the same source. When you’re online you are looking for information – for content – and the more in-depth, the better.

That’s my thinking as to why electronic banner advertising through the traditional magazine’s newsletter outperformed the product-oriented tabloid’s Web site. Does this conclusion stand up in your opinion?